Tuesday, March 13, 2007

Second Stanza onwards

If you aspire for liberation, my child, reject objectivism as poison and yearn for truth, contentment, compassion and grace

This what the words really translate into. Original sanskrit words are Ksama, Daya, tosa, satyam. Forgiveness to me dosent sound right, it should be grace for Ksama. Tosa is definitely contentment. Satyam would be truth. Daya would be compassion.
Having looked at the word play, let us look at the premises.
Do all that we see is not truth? Is there any other truth that has not manifested itself in this world that we need to seek it? And further more if any truth as that is not within our experience can we find it by seeking it?
Contentment can not be sought. Can it be? By seeking contentment you are becoming discontent or is it incorrect to say that? It is a state of the mind

Stanza three
You are neither water nor earth, nor fire nor space nor air. In order to attain freedom know the self to be the witness to all these the embodiment of pure consciosuness itself.
A little bit of explain is in order here. The ancient indians considered the human body to be made of five elements. Even now the interpretation has not changed but gained a finer granularity. Here the teacher says You are not the body. Ok I am not the body I am the embodiment of pure consciousnesss. Is this consciouness not a function of the physical body. I argue this point a little. I say that without the body there can be no experience. It is the body that permits us to experience all sorts of consciousness, normal or paranormal or otherwise. The sense of witness is also a function of this physical body. At least, there is a theoritical impossibility to the claim that the human being can experience anything that is not a function of his organic body. SO to start with the claim is incorrect at to my mind. If we say this to prevent the man from enjoying gross sensual pleasures, I think it a totally sick way of looking at any pleasure that the body is capable of giving you. At least that is one interpretation.What is a human being without his/her physical form? All subtle and gross is within the capability of the body. I may say this from the standpoint of the creator, HE must find joy in both. To be a witness to what? I think participation mystique is a much stronger and effective argument. I wish to be a part of this, whatever is going here, not that I understand much of what is going on this little planet that we call ours. I wish to be part of this wholly, fully without respite and enjoy everything that comes with being a man. And look at this, now comes along my ancients and tell me the body is not yours. Ha Ha, do you honestly think I will listen?

Stanza four
If you detach yourself from the body and abide in consciousness you will at once become happy peacful and free from bondage.

Take it from me. I say from personal experience you wont be happy, nor be peaceful, nor be free from any bondage. You will be more miserable as a witness. Your miserable state will continue and become more acute the more witness you become to this farce that is going on here within and without. There is a creator without doubt, but that issue is not discussed here. That there is a design to our bodies is also without doubt but witness was I am sure not in the agenda of our creation.

No comments: